Baseball Egg

Baseball for Egg Heads

The 20 Greatest Twins of All-Time according to WAR

By Dan Holmes ♦ December 21, 2018
Tony Oliva, Rod Carew, Kent Hrbek, and Joe Mauer.

In this, the latest installment of my series on franchise leaders, I focus on the greatest Twins of all-time. At least according to Wins Above Replacement, otherwise known as WAR.

The Twins are the same franchise that started as a charter member of the American League in 1901 as the Washington Nationals (though unofficially dubbed the “Senators” by the newspapers). The AL was a “rebel league” at that time, a group of wool-wearing scoundrels threatening the monopoly on professional baseball held by the senior National League. In 1960, after years of being the league doormat, the Senators packed their belongings and moved west to Minnesota. Specifically St. Paul, where they’ve been the Twins (after Twin Cities) ever since. They’ve had a little more success in the midwest, winning three pennants and two World Series titles since the move. The Senators managed only three pennants and one title in their six decades in D.C.

20. Dave Goltz

Goltz signed a six-year, $3 million contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers as a free agent after the 1979 season. Free agency was still pretty new at the time, but the Twins lost at least one player each year because Calvin Griffith was cheap. A starting pitcher, Goltz cashed in after a few very good years on the hill for Minnesota, but he tanked in LA.

In his eight seasons with the Twins, Goltz accumulated 24.3 WAR. But after going west for the millions, he posted a -2.3 WAR in five years for the Dodgers and Angels. The righthander was one of the first free agent busts. By his second year in Dodger blue, manager Tommy Lasorda was using Goltz out of the bullpen. In Game Four of the ’81 World Series he relieved starter Bob Welch in the first inning after his teammate was unable to retire a batter. The Dodgers came back to win that game 8-7, and Goltz won a World Series ring when the team defeated the Yankees in six games.

Goltz was raised in Rothsay, a tiny town in northwest Minnesota which is known for a giant plaster chicken that serves as a tourist attraction. He was a highly-recruited prep athlete, starring in track, basketball, football, and baseball. Goltz was 6’4 and 200 pounds as a 17-year old. He was sort of a Paul Bunyon figure. He became the eighth native Minnesotan to play for the Twins.

Like many pitchers of the 1970s, Goltz was burned out from overuse. When he was 28 years old he started 39 games and completed 19, pitching an unhealthy 303 innings. He and Jim Palmer are the last American League pitchers to throw as many as 300 innings.

19. Justin Morneau

The New York Yankees have had eight different players win a batting title. Already, since joining the NL in 1993, the Colorado Rockies have eight batting champions. Those eight players have won a total of 10 batting titles in the 24 years since the Rockies became a big league club. And there’s likely a lot more to come.

But outside of the Tigers, who’ve had more batting champions and more titles than any other franchise, the Twins have been a batting title factory of sorts since they pulled into the Twin Cities. Tony Oliva won a pair of titles in the mid-1960s, and Rod Carew began his dominance a few years later, snagging seven total in the ten-year stretch from 1969 to 1978. Oliva won again in 1971 and probably would have won two or three more if he’d stayed healthy. He was a remarkable hitter, but more on him later.

Kirby Puckett got his title in 1989, and then Joe Mauer picked up three in a four-year stretch. That gave the Twins 13 batting titles in 45 years, an average of one per 3.5 seasons. In all, only four players have won titles for Minnesota, but all four were great hitters, and could all be in the Hall of Fame. More on that later too.

Morneau won his batting title for the Rockies in his first season in Denver, although he hit “only” .319 that year. He wasn’t helped that much by his home park: he hit .327 at Coors and .309 on the road.

Morneau’s MVP award in 2006 was one of the worst decisions by the voters. There were at least 15 position players who had a better season than him in ’06, and a few pitchers too. But Morneau drove in 130 runs and wore a glove in the field, and voters loved that type of thing back then. Grady Sizemore or Carlos Guillen or Derek Jeter would have been vastly more deserving of the honor.

18. Cesar Tovar

I once asked Tommy John to name the toughest batter he faced. He named Tovar. Mel Stottlemyre said Tovar also. Later I asked the same question of Mickey Lolich and he gave me the same name: Cesar Tovar.

Tovar was from Caracas. There have been dozens of players from that capital city of Venezuela to make the big leagues since Tovar debuted, but Tovar was a pioneer. He was the first non-shortstop from Venezuela to get a regular crack at playing in the United States and he was also the first non-star who made a career in the majors. Prior to Tovar there had been Chico Carrasquel and Luis Aparicio, both great shortstops, and then there was Vic Davalillo, an outfielder who ended up making one All-Star team in the States. But Tovar was the first “utility” type player from that country to be given a shot. That was significant because it marked a turning point where American scouts started to identify bit players in Latin countries who could be signed and developed. Prior to that the few black Latin players in MLB were superstars.

Tovar was famously versatile: he played at least 200 games at five different positions, and once played all nine defensive positions in a single game. He never really had a regular position. In 1967 he played 70 games at the hot corner, 64 in center field, and 36 at second base. The Twins also started him in left field ten times. He played every game that year, scored 98 runs, had 32 doubles, and 19 stolen bases. He finished seventh in MVP voting despite not having a set position. He had several years like that.

Why did he pester John, Stottlemyre, and Lolich so much? Tovar was a slap hitter, a contact hitter. He didn’t strike out much and he liked to push the ball to the right (opposite) side of the diamond. He was a great bunter, and I mean really great. Carew became the best bunter in the game, and one of the best ever. Tovar tutored Carew on his bunting.

I looked it up, and sure enough, Tovar wore out John, Lolich, and Stottlemyre. He hit .367 against the three lefthanders. That’s Ty Cobb territory. He batted over .400 against Lolich. Tovar was a .278 career hitter for 12 seasons.

17. Torii Hunter

Somewhere else on the internet I wrote something about the most popular Twins of all-time. I figured that it came down to four players: Bert Blyleven, Kirby Puckett, Kent Hrbek, and Hunter. As is normal for those type of things, all four of them were fun players. That’s usually the case, think about Mantle and Ford on the Yankees and Norm Cash with the Tigers, and Mark Grace and George Brett with the Cubs and Royals. Tony Gwynn and the Padres, of course. The favorites can be great players, but they have to be fun and approachable. Sometimes a non-superstar is the favorite, like Javy Baez on the Cubs right now and Kevin Millar a few years ago with the “Bunch of Idiots” Red Sox.

Twins’ fans have always had a very special relationship with their team. I suspect that has something to do with the nature of Minnesota and the upper midwest. Minnesotans are not pretentious, they’re salt-of-the-earth types, and loyal. Give them a team of hustling ballplayers, of good, fun-loving fellas, and they’re happy. In the 1960s it was Bob Allison and Tony O and the flamboyant shortstop Zoilo Versalles. Like your favorite uncle, Blyleven was a prankster, a guy with the clever one-liner and the hop in his step. He was the “pull my finger” sort. Puckett, like Griffey Jr. and later Miguel Cabrera, smiled a lot on the diamond. Fans love that. Hrbek was a hard-working player and as a local boy, he fit right in. Joe Mauer too of course, but he was never quite as lovable as “Herbie.”

Hunter might be the most popular Twin ever (it’s either him or Kirby). He had that brilliant smile, he was a great player, and he was an even better team leader and teammate. Later in his short stays with Detroit and the Angels, he was instantly adopted as a fan favorite and established himself as a clubhouse leader. He just had that in him.

16. Gary Gaetti

Famously, there have been two future Hall of Famers who hit a home run in their first major league at-bat. The first was Earl Averill, the second was pitcher Hoyt Wilhelm. Among players who have hit a homer in their first trip to the plate, Gaetti has the most career home runs, 360.

Gaetti also hit home runs in his first two postseason at-bats, a record unmatched as of 2018. He liked to make a good first impression.

After the 1990 season, one of his worst, Gaetti left the Twins as a free agent. It was an agonizing decision that he later regretted.

“There were a lot of things that went into that decision,” Gaetti said. “It was real hard leaving there. I went through a tough time leaving and then coming back and having to play against the Twins. That was no fun, getting booed out of the stadium, but that’s all part of it. Looking back on it, would I have made the same decision? Probably not.”

15. Frank Viola

The greatest pitcher to ever sport a handlebar mustache. A few of the lefthanders that had a lesser career than Viola: Billy Pierce, Ron Guidry, Mickey Lolich, Jimmy Key, Vida Blue, Jim Kaat, Kenny Rogers, and Boomer Wells.

14. Jim Perry

The tall righthander from North Carolina won 128 games for Minnesota in ten years, including 56 in the three years the team finished in first place. He was the first Twin to win the Cy Young Award, and yes he threw a spitter like his younger brother.

13. Bob Allison

A Kirk Gibson-type player: he was strong and fast, a fearless runner, and a power hitter. Allison was a football and baseball star at the University of Kansas, most likely could have played in the NFL.

In Game Two of the 1965 World Series, Allison made a tremendous backhanded grab of a low sinking line drive in right field. Twins’ fans simply call it “The Catch.” 

12. Johan Santana

Sandy Koufax-lite. Santana had seven seasons where he made 25 starts or more, and he finished in the top five in Cy Young voting in five of them, winning twice. Three strikeout titles, three ERA titles, a no-hitter. Santana did a lot of the things Koufax did, but not to quite the degree.

But, you may be surprised at how close the two pitchers are in value. Here’s how WAR sees Koufax and Santana:

  WAR WAR7 WAR3 WAR1
Koufax 49.0 48.7 29.1 10.7
Santana 51.6 44.2 23.2 8.7

Sure, Koufax was better at his very peak, but Santana isn’t far behind in his best seven seasons and he tops Sandy in career WAR. A persuasive Hall of Fame case could made for Santana, but ultimately he doesn’t have the non-statistical achievements or narrative. Had the Twins made a few World Series, that would help his candidacy.

11. Jim Kaat

An unusual pitcher with unique skills, Kaat might have been the hardest-working pitcher of his time. When he got to the big leagues, Kaat did not have a strong move to first base. He worked at it and eventually had one of the best pickoff moves anyone had seen. When he was a young prospect Kaat was prone to mental lapses in the field. He worked on it and became one of the best fielding pitchers in history, winning 16 Gold Gloves. Every year or so, Kaat would arrive in spring camp with anew goal: improve his breaking ball, add a new pitch, become a better bunter. Whatever. That constant improvement seems to have kept him young, and he pitched 25 years. The last five years of his career he found a new challenge: becoming a lefthanded situational relief pitcher, which he conquered as well. 

Holds the record for most wins by a Minnesota pitcher, with 190, and also pitched the most innings and made the most starts. 

10. Camilo Pascual

Ted Williams said Pascual had the “most feared curve ball in the American League for 18 years.” Pascual’s curve was a true overhand pitch, dropping from “noon to six” as if off a table.

The Cuban righthander known as “Little Potato” pitched seven years for Washington and six years for the franchise after they moved to Minnesota. Like Santana, he won three straight strikeout titles, most with that frustrating hook. 

9. Chuck Knoblauch

Undersized, never really comfortable in the field, but Knoblauch was a winner. He was a run waiting to score, a team-first guy who helped the Twins to the World Series title in his rookie season and was a starter on four more pennant-winners with the Yankees.

In 1996 Knoblauch scored a franchise record 140 runs, had 197 hits, hit .341, and stole 45 bases, but finished 16th in MVP voting. Eight of the fifteen players in front of him were later implicated as having used steroids. 

8. Kent Hrbek

Selected in the 17th round of the 1978 MLB Draft out of Kennedy High School in Bloomington, Minnesota. Hrbek was one of a group of good ballplayers the franchise drafted and developed in that era. The others included:

1978: Kent Hrbek (17th round)
1979: Gary Gaetti (2nd), Randy Bush (2nd) and Tim Laudner (3rd)
1980: Tim Teufel (2nd) and Jim Eisenreich (16th)
1981: Frank Viola (2nd)
1982: Kirby Puckett (1st)

“Herbie” was the hometown kid and an immediate star in his rookie season in 1981 when he hit .301 with 23 homers and 92 RBI. He continued to be an All-Star caliber player the rest of the decade but aged quickly in his early 30s.

7. Tony Oliva

Few players in history could hit a baseball as well as Oliva.

In his first eight seasons, Olive finished first, second, or third in the batting race seven times. He won the batting title three times, led the league in hits five times, and in doubles four times.

Chronic knee and back problems hindered his career after his 32nd birthday, but Oliva still hit .304 with more than 1,900 hits in 15 seasons, all with the Twins.

The Twins nearly lost Oliva shortly after they shepherded the young Cuban to the United States. Minnesota brought him up immediately to the big league team in 1962 and he hit well, but the following spring they had a glut of outfielders and released Oliva. With nowhere to go, with no family in the U.S, Oliva followed another Minnesota prospect to North Carolina where the other fellow was going to play minor league ball. Oliva worked out with the team and quickly impressed the manager, who begged the Twins to resign him. They did, and the following season he won Rookie of the Year and the first of two straight batting championships.

6. Brad Radke

Bet you didn’t expect Radke to be the second-highest ranked pitcher. Sort of a Jack Morris-type, Radke was solid, efficient, and durable, but rarely exceptional. He got the job done and kept his team in games. He topped 200 innings nine times in his 12-year career before a torn labrum forced him to retire.

5. Bert Blyleven

Leads all Minnesota pitchers in WAR, strikeouts, complete games, and shutouts, ranks second to Kaat in wins, 190-149.

Blyleven was a master prankster. He probably gave out more hot foots than anyone in baseball history. He was also famous for putting bubble gum on the top of his teammates’ caps.

Like Pascual and Viola, Blyleven had an elite curve ball. He rarely topped 90-91 miles per hour with his fastball, but the important thing with him was the relative difference in velocity between his primary pitches. Blyleven’s curve was a tight, dropping pitch that was about 7-8 miles per hour slower than his fastball. He had great control of the pitch. 

He was very durable, and in the year he got his 3,000th strikeout he also led the league in that category. His 60 career shutouts rank ninth and are the most by a pitcher who relied heavily on his curve ball.  

4. Kirby Puckett

Not a good person, but a fun baseball player until an eye injury ended his career.

3. Joe Mauer

Seems certain to be the fourth Minneapolis/St. Paul native to play for the Twins who will be elected to the Hall of Fame. That would join him with Paul Molitor, Jack Morris, and Dave Winfield.

Mauer might have been a quarterback in the NFL, he was a highly-regarded gridiron prospect coming out of high school. 

2. Harmon Killebrew

Killebrew’s wife once admonished him for letting his kids play on their newly planted grass. Harmon replied, “We’re not raising grass, we’re raising boys.”

Killebrew had a distinct home run style: the baseball soared high and deep, seemed to stay in the air forever. At one point he held the record for the longest home run hit in five different American League ballparks. 

1. Rod Carew

Five facts about Rod Carew:

  1. Carew’s mother went into labor with her son while on a train in the Panama Canal Zone. A doctor on the train delivered the little Carew child. That doctor’s name was Rodney Cline, which is why the Hall of Famer is named Rodney Cline Carew.
  2. The three pitchers Carew faced the most often were Jim Palmer, Luis Tiant, and Catfish Hunter. In just over 3oo at-bats against the trio, Carew hit .353 with 16 doubles, five triples, and 10 home runs.
  3. In 1983 when he was 37 years old, Carew got off to one of the hottest starts in baseball history. In April he had ten multiple-hit games, including a five-hit game in the opener of a weekend series against Baltimore. Two days later he had four hits against the Orioles to raise his average to .453 on April 24. He kept at it in May, starting the month off with another four-hit game. Five days later he had his fifth straight multi-hit game and boosted his season average to .500 (48-for-96). He had 12 multi-hit games in May, and he was hitting .443 as June started. He had a 13-game hitting streak in June but his average actually fell 29 points. At the All-Star break he was hitting .402 with 92 hits in 58 games (he missed two weeks with an injury). Carew played the second half with the nagging injury and his average dropped, eventually resting at .339, second in the league.
  4. The 1983 season was one of the two years Carew was hitting over .390 at the All-Star break. The other was 1977 when he was batting .394 on his way to his sixth batting title.
  5. Four times, in 1975 and in each year from 1977-79, Carew was the highest vote-getter in All-Star Game balloting. Carew was selected for the All-Star team 18 times. As of 2018, Carew has received more fan votes than any player in All-Star game history. (Voting was conducted by managers, players and coaches from 1958 to 1968).

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *