Baseball Egg

Baseball for Egg Heads

The 20 Greatest Orioles of All-Time according to WAR

By Dan Holmes ♦ January 3, 2019
Four high-flying birds: Adam Jones, Melvin Mora, Paul Blair, and Frank Robinson.

Once upon a time, the Baltimore Orioles were baseball’s model franchise. From the mid-1960s to the early 1980s, the Orioles were the most successful team in the game. They won pennants in 1966, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1979, and 1983. Twice they were crowned World Champions.

Over a 19-year period, the Orioles averaged 92 wins and finished first eight times. They were guided by a philosophy known as “The Oriole Way”, a series of rules and methodologies that produced winning players and teams built on defense, pitching, and the three-run homer.

As of the end of 2018, the following players constitute the top twenty players in Orioles’ history according to Wins Above Replacement (WAR).

20. Rafael Palmeiro

The once proud Baltimore franchise, the best organization in baseball for more than two decades, was stained in the 1990s by a long line of players who used performance-enhancing drugs. Many of them were caught, failed tests, or admitted their usage years after the fact. Palmeiro is the poster boy for that dirty era of Baltimore baseball. He played seven seasons in the city in two stints with the O’s. The team welcomed him back for the final two years of his career so he could get his 3,000th hit. After he adamantly told a congressional hearing that he had never used steroids (“not once ever”), he failed a test and was shamed.

A few of the other Orioles who have been implicated in steroid use: Brady Anderson, Brian Roberts, Miguel Tejada, Jason Grimsley, David Segui, Jay Gibbons, and Chris Davis. Others suspected were Geronimo Berroa, Lenny Webster, Mike Bordick, Chris Hoiles, Jeffrey Hammonds, and even Melvin Mora. For a brief spell, just to make the team an “official sponsor of cheating”, Sammy Sosa was in an Orioles’ uniform.

The other team of that era that was riddled with steroid users was the Texas Rangers. There were two prominent common denominators on those teams: Palmeiro and manager Johnny Oates, a man who must have gotten used to stepping lightly around syringes.

What to say about Palmeiro, a Faustian character we haven’t seen in the game since Hal Chase? Well, like Chase, Raffi was a popular player with wonderful baseball skills who decided to break the rules to enhance his wallet. Many observers considered Chase the greatest first baseman of the first two decades of the 20th century, a player worthy of the greatest honor, the Hall of Fame, had he not been driven from the game due to fixing games. Palmeiro is destined to be a shining example of sliminess: a wonderful player on paper, but a terrible character who would be more appropriate as a villain in a Sherlock Holmes novel.

19. Al Bumbry

Before he played a game in the big leagues, Bumbry stared death in the eyes during a stint in Vietnam in the U.S. Army. Bumbry was a tank platoon leader, responsible for 45 men and the equipment in his platoon. He won a Bronze Star for his bravery and leadership. When he returned to the States, he was 24 years old, a more mature man, more mature player. He quickly navigated his way through the Orioles’ organization and in 1973 he was in the outfield, playing alongside Paul Blair and Don Baylor. He won the American League Rookie of the Year, batted .337 and showed off his speed.

Bumbry settled in as a useful center fielder for Earl Weaver after Blair left Baltimore, and he was an All-Star in 1980 when he had 205 hits. He was often platooned and rarely faced left-handed hitters, except for a few seasons.

18. Dave McNally

“McNally was a tenacious guy and really stubborn,” Jim Palmer once said. “He won 20 games four times. When I was injured I would sit in the stands and watch him, and I learned how to pitch.”

In 1971, McNally, Palmer, Mike Cuellar, and Pat Dobson each won 20 games, the last time a team had four 20-game winners on their staff. McNally actually missed five weeks that season with a sore arm, but when he went on the shelf he already had 13 victories. When he came back in August he got back on track, and in early September he shut out the Yankees to clinch the division title and record his 20th win. Within six days, the Orioles saw all four men win their 20th game.

McNally was the Orioles’ winningest pitcher when he asked to be traded in 1975 for a change of scenery. The probable reason for his request was the multiple contract squabbles he had with the front office. He spent a failed season in Montreal, served as one of the players who challenged the reserve clause, and retired. He was one of the most popular pitchers to ever wear the Orioles’ uniform.

“Dave was an unbelievable competitor,” remembered Earl Weaver. “He did it with cunning and intelligence. He loved to set you up with a change, fool you with that tremendous curve and then throw the fastball by you. Plus he was 100 percent gentleman. He was the kind of guy you wanted your son to be.”

17. Nick Markakis

Markakis is a quiet player, known for being pretty low-key in the clubhouse.

“Go about your business, mind your own business,” Markakis has said. “Do what you’re supposed to do, and not such much with the mouth, but by example.”

He was a center fielder out of position in right field, but it worked because he played to the left of Adam Jones. The pair won six Gold Gloves together in the Baltimore outfield.

16. Brian Roberts

I wrote somewhere else that there are three types of doubles hitters:

  1. Aggressive base runners who stretch their share of singles into doubles.
  2. Power hitters who hit the ball over outfielders or in the gaps.
  3. Guys who pull the ball down the lines a lot.

Roberts was a combination of #1 and #3, but mostly he was #3. A switch-hitter, he was a pull-hitter, yanked a lot of balls down the chalk. Only five players have hit 50 doubles three times or more, all of the others are immortals. There’s Tris Speaker (who did it five times), Paul Waner, Stan Musial, Albert Pujols, and finally Roberts. Talk about a misfit.

15. Melvin Mora

Baseball history has witnessed few players like Mora. He spent seven plus years in the minor leagues with two organizations struggling to get a chance. He was 32 years old before he got a permanent position in the lineup. That year, he suddenly hit .340 with 27 home runs as Baltimore’s third baseman. He had two great seasons, two good seasons, and was average or below average every year besides that. His unusual spike in productivity after the age of 30 is certainly suspicious. But hey, he got paid: made more than $40 million playing a game.

14. Ken Singleton

Forty times the player Mora was and four million times the person. Singleton was a high percentage player and a gentleman. He was one of Earl Weaver’s favorites, a switch-hitter with power and a great eye from both sides of the plate.

Prior to the 1979 World Series when the Pittsburgh staff was going over the scouting reports on Baltimore’s lineup, Bert Blyleven was asked about Singleton, whom he’d faced when he was in the American League. “He can hit it up, hit it down, hit the fast ones and the curves,” Blyleven said, “the best option is to walk his ass.”

13. Manny Machado

I don’t write comments for all the players, it’s “not my cup of tea.”

12. Adam Jones

Only Ripken, Robinson, and Murray have more hits in a Baltimore uniform than Jones, who ranks in the top ten in almost every offensive category for the franchise.

Sort of Chet Lemon-light, right down to the boneheaded base running. Jones could go get ’em, and he had some pop in his bat, but like Lemon, he’s aging out in his mid-30s.

11. Frank Robinson

Was said to be an “old thirty” when the Reds traded him to Baltimore. Robinson won the triple crown his first season with the O’s, becoming the first player to win the MVP in both leagues. Without Robby, there’s no “Oriole Way”, no dynasty, no extended string of success in Baltimore. He was the anchor in the lineup, the leader in the clubhouse, the judge in the kangaroo court.

A lot of people forget how great Robinson was. Think of Hank Aaron and remove about 5 percent, that was Frank Robinson.

10. Brady Anderson

If Frank Robinson signified the beginning of the Oriole dynasty, Brady Anderson and his sideburns signaled the end. Probably added five years to his career through pharmaceuticals. Otherwise, he was Chris Singleton.

9. Boog Powell

Powell ended his career in 1977 with the Dodgers for a few months. The Dodger Stadium concession stands had a menu item called “Helmet Nachos” that was quite literally, a Dodgers’ batting helmet filled with greasy nachos. According to legend, during one game that summer when he wasn’t in the lineup, Powell had a bat boy get him Helmet Nachos and proceeded to scarf them down in the clubhouse. Manager Tommy Lasorda summoned Boog to pinch hit mid-nacho, and the big slugger put the cheese-filled helmet on his head and went into the game.

8. Bobby Grich

The best defensive infields in the history of baseball were the Baltimore group from 1972 to 1975, that had Grich at second base, Mark Belanger at shortstop, and Brooks Robinson at third base. Grich, Robinson, and Belanger won 15 of the 16 Gold Glove Awards available in those four seasons. Boog Powell, who started in three of those years, was no slouch, and Lee May was very good around the bag at first base in 1975.

In those four seasons the Orioles allowed 114 fewer unearned runs than any other team in the American League. They led their league in pitching each season, naturally. With that airtight infield and Paul Blair and Al Bumbry in the outfield, Baltimore didn’t make many mistakes in the field.

Grich’s strength was his anticipation and sure hands. Three times he handled as many as 900 chances, a feat only matched by Bill Mazeroski. He ranks among the ten greatest defensive second basemen in history, even if Cooperstown has snubbed him.

“I didn’t have Brooks Robinson’s hands, Mark Belanger’s range or Joe Morgan’s quickness,” Grich said, “but I got to more balls than other guys who were 6 feet 2 and 200 pounds because, on every pitch, I got a jump. I cheated so much, I caught balls on the outfield grass and threw guys out.”

7. Paul Blair

One man’s selection of the best center fielders of all-time:

  1. Tris Speaker
  2. Willie Mays
  3. Andruw Jones
  4. Paul Blair
  5. Richie Ashburn
  6. Chet Lemon
  7. Gary Pettis
  8. Willie Davis
  9. Garry Maddox
  10. Scoops Carey

Some players are fast, some are quick (there’s a difference). Some outfielders have a great first step, and some have excellent instincts. Blair had all of that, and his arm was good too. Really a prototypical center fielder.

6. Mark Belanger

Everyone knows Mark Belanger was a phenomenal shortstop, he’s one of the ten best to ever play the position. Most people also know he was a pretty dreadful hitter. It wouldn’t surprise you, I suppose, that Belanger was 4-for-48 (.083) against Gaylord Perry, or that he was 2-for-22 off Rollie Fingers. But you’d probably be shocked to know that Belanger hit .421 (8-for-19 with three doubles) off Goose Gossage. Sometimes, those things don’t make sense.

Belanger was a winner. His American Legion team (Pittsfield, Massachusetts) finished third in the country his senior year. In the minor leagues his teams won three titles in four years. In his 16 full seasons with Baltimore, the team won 90 games or more 13 times. In his professional career his teams finished in first place ten times.

5. Mike Mussina

Who was the greatest Orioles’ pitcher of all-time? Jim Palmer rates higher in career WAR because he spent his entire career in Baltimore, while Moose only pitched ten years for the team. But we can answer the question by looking at their peak performance for the franchise.

Best 3Best 5Best 7
Mike Mussina20.030.940.3
Jim Palmer22.535.346.9

Clearly Palmer was more valuable, though both were excellent. Mussina deserves to be in the Hall of Fame, and he’ll get there eventually. Palmer had a larger impact because he was a tad better and he pitched about 25 more innings per season.

4. Eddie Murray

It became commonplace to describe Eddie Murray as aloof, distant, grouchy. He didn’t talk to the media much, so he was almost always called “quiet” too. But Eddie Murray is a fun guy, he has a great personality. He likes to laugh, he enjoys it. But Eddie didn’t trust people, and early in his professional baseball career a few reporters screwed him over, so he was very careful after that. He gave most of the media his “bad ass face.” But it was a mask, a protective device. Among his friends, those people he trusted, Murray was gregarious and known for his loud, booming laugh.

3. Jim Palmer

See the Mussina comment.

2. Brooks Robinson

Robinson was a second baseman when he signed with Baltimore, spurning offers from several teams. He chose the Orioles because the franchise was so bad, he figured it would be much easier to get to the big leagues. He was right, but as a young prospect, Robinson did not impress everyone.

“He couldn’t hit, he couldn’t run, and his arm wasn’t that strong,” teammate Gen Woodling said when he saw the 19-year old Robinson in spring training.

True, Robinson was far from flashy as an athlete, but he was efficient, fundamentally sound, and nearly perfect as a defender. The Orioles groomed him to replace veteran George Kell at third, and once Robinson got the job he held it for two decades.

There are four players whose defensive statistics stand out as freakishly good: Ozzie Smith, Bill Mazeroski, Tris Speaker, and Robinson.

1. Cal Ripken Jr.

The last man to bat at Memorial Stadium and the man who “built” Camden Yards. Ripken was on deck on October 6, 2001, in Baltimore awaiting his last at-bat in his final game, but teammate Brady Anderson, also playing his last game for the O’s, struck out to end the game.


Tagged with:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *