1 | Johnny Bench 1967—1983 | 69.9 CAREER | 43.5 LONG PEAK | 22.0 SHORT PEAK | 30.2 PRIME | 27.2 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 302.0 TOTAL |
2 | Josh Gibson 1930—1946 | 59.9 CAREER | 46.7 LONG PEAK | 25.1 SHORT PEAK | 36.4 PRIME | CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 299.5 TOTAL |
3 | Gary Carter 1974—1992 | 66.6 CAREER | 44.6 LONG PEAK | 21.4 SHORT PEAK | 33.1 PRIME | 3.6 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 299.2 TOTAL |
4 | Carlton Fisk 1969—1993 | 64.5 CAREER | 35.1 LONG PEAK | 18.7 SHORT PEAK | 21.4 PRIME | 3.2 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 252.3 TOTAL |
5 | Joe Mauer 2004—2018 | 53.5 CAREER | 37.7 LONG PEAK | 18.9 SHORT PEAK | 28.0 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 247.8 TOTAL |
6 | Yogi Berra 1946—1965 | 52.4 CAREER | 32.4 LONG PEAK | 15.3 SHORT PEAK | 24.2 PRIME | 43.4 CHWAR | -0.5 ADJ | 229.3 TOTAL |
7 | Buster Posey 2009—2021 | 44.2 CAREER | 36.1 LONG PEAK | 18.5 SHORT PEAK | 28.7 PRIME | 16.9 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 229.1 TOTAL |
8 | Ivan Rodriguez 1991—2011 | 51.6 CAREER | 29.7 LONG PEAK | 14.5 SHORT PEAK | 28.5 PRIME | 7.6 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 228.5 TOTAL |
9 | Thurman Munson 1969—1979 | 45.6 CAREER | 34.1 LONG PEAK | 17.8 SHORT PEAK | 24.9 PRIME | 13.4 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 219.9 TOTAL |
10 | Ted Simmons 1968—1988 | 46.4 CAREER | 32.0 LONG PEAK | 14.9 SHORT PEAK | 21.1 PRIME | 3.3 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 206.2 TOTAL |
11 | Bill Dickey 1928—1946 | 47.7 CAREER | 29.9 LONG PEAK | 15.1 SHORT PEAK | 21.9 PRIME | 33.7 CHWAR | -6.6 ADJ | 203.2 TOTAL |
12 | Mike Piazza 1992—2007 | 38.7 CAREER | 27.4 LONG PEAK | 14.2 SHORT PEAK | 28.7 PRIME | 5.1 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 197.7 TOTAL |
13 | Bill Freehan 1961—1976 | 40.9 CAREER | 30.8 LONG PEAK | 16.7 SHORT PEAK | 20.6 PRIME | 7.0 CHWAR | 2.2 ADJ | 196.4 TOTAL |
14 | Jorge Posada 1995—2011 | 40.0 CAREER | 30.9 LONG PEAK | 15.8 SHORT PEAK | 21.8 PRIME | 20.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 195.4 TOTAL |
15 | Roy Campanella 1937—1957 | 38.1 CAREER | 30.6 LONG PEAK | 16.5 SHORT PEAK | 23.5 PRIME | 21.1 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 195.3 TOTAL |
16 | Mickey Cochrane 1925—1937 | 40.6 CAREER | 29.9 LONG PEAK | 14.6 SHORT PEAK | 22.3 PRIME | 24.0 CHWAR | -3.4 ADJ | 191.9 TOTAL |
17 | Yadier Molina 2004—2021 | 41.0 CAREER | 27.8 LONG PEAK | 16.0 SHORT PEAK | 21.7 PRIME | 8.2 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 191.0 TOTAL |
18 | Joe Torre 1960—1977 | 52.7 CAREER | 34.0 LONG PEAK | 16.3 SHORT PEAK | 23.5 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -43.0 ADJ | 185.2 TOTAL |
19 | Gene Tenace 1969—1983 | 43.8 CAREER | 32.2 LONG PEAK | 15.0 SHORT PEAK | 23.4 PRIME | 12.5 CHWAR | -22.0 ADJ | 184.9 TOTAL |
20 | Jim Sundberg 1974—1989 | 39.1 CAREER | 28.2 LONG PEAK | 14.9 SHORT PEAK | 19.7 PRIME | 1.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 181.9 TOTAL |
21 | Gabby Hartnett 1922—1941 | 47.2 CAREER | 25.7 LONG PEAK | 12.5 SHORT PEAK | 17.1 PRIME | 10.3 CHWAR | -8.3 ADJ | 179.0 TOTAL |
22 | Jason Kendall 1996—2010 | 39.0 CAREER | 28.5 LONG PEAK | 13.7 SHORT PEAK | 18.7 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 179.0 TOTAL |
23 | Darrell Porter 1971—1987 | 38.3 CAREER | 26.7 LONG PEAK | 14.5 SHORT PEAK | 16.8 PRIME | 7.1 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 173.3 TOTAL |
24 | Lance Parrish 1977—1995 | 37.6 CAREER | 26.3 LONG PEAK | 13.2 SHORT PEAK | 18.1 PRIME | 2.8 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 170.9 TOTAL |
25 | Russell Martin 2006—2019 | 37.8 CAREER | 26.0 LONG PEAK | 14.6 SHORT PEAK | 16.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 168.4 TOTAL |
26 | Biz Mackey 1920—1947 | 39.4 CAREER | 24.4 LONG PEAK | 13.4 SHORT PEAK | 16.6 PRIME | CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 168.1 TOTAL |
27 | Salvador Perez 2011—2021 | 31.6 CAREER | 25.8 LONG PEAK | 14.5 SHORT PEAK | 14.7 PRIME | 5.9 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 152.9 TOTAL |
28 | Brian McCann 2005—2019 | 31.0 CAREER | 23.8 LONG PEAK | 13.0 SHORT PEAK | 17.1 PRIME | 1.2 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 151.1 TOTAL |
29 | Mickey Tettleton 1984—1997 | 29.1 CAREER | 22.9 LONG PEAK | 13.8 SHORT PEAK | 19.2 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 150.5 TOTAL |
30 | Roger Bresnahan 1897—1915 | 33.9 CAREER | 24.6 LONG PEAK | 12.9 SHORT PEAK | 18.4 PRIME | 3.7 CHWAR | -11.4 ADJ | 149.5 TOTAL |
31 | Elston Howard 1955—1968 | 26.4 CAREER | 24.1 LONG PEAK | 14.5 SHORT PEAK | 18.7 PRIME | 20.2 CHWAR | 0.6 ADJ | 149.4 TOTAL |
32 | Wally Schang 1913—1931 | 40.1 CAREER | 21.1 LONG PEAK | 10.1 SHORT PEAK | 14.4 PRIME | 16.2 CHWAR | -9.2 ADJ | 148.6 TOTAL |
33 | J.T. Realmuto 2014—2021 | 24.9 CAREER | 24.9 LONG PEAK | 13.4 SHORT PEAK | 18.2 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 143.1 TOTAL |
34 | Manny Sanguillen 1967—1980 | 25.5 CAREER | 24.4 LONG PEAK | 12.6 SHORT PEAK | 17.4 PRIME | 5.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 141.6 TOTAL |
35 | Tony Pena 1980—1997 | 23.8 CAREER | 23.5 LONG PEAK | 12.8 SHORT PEAK | 19.2 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 139.9 TOTAL |
36 | Javy Lopez 1992—2006 | 27.6 CAREER | 23.1 LONG PEAK | 14.0 SHORT PEAK | 14.2 PRIME | 3.3 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 139.4 TOTAL |
37 | Ernie Lombardi 1931—1947 | 32.9 CAREER | 20.8 LONG PEAK | 10.2 SHORT PEAK | 14.7 PRIME | 6.0 CHWAR | -3.5 ADJ | 139.0 TOTAL |
38 | Louis Santop 1910—1926 | 32.5 CAREER | 20.8 LONG PEAK | 11.4 SHORT PEAK | 12.9 PRIME | CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 138.5 TOTAL |
39 | Victor Martinez 2002—2018 | 30.7 CAREER | 27.2 LONG PEAK | 14.4 SHORT PEAK | 16.5 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -19.0 ADJ | 137.4 TOTAL |
40 | Del Crandall 1949—1966 | 27.4 CAREER | 21.9 LONG PEAK | 12.1 SHORT PEAK | 15.4 PRIME | 6.3 CHWAR | -0.3 ADJ | 136.5 TOTAL |
41 | Tom Haller 1961—1972 | 26.6 CAREER | 21.8 LONG PEAK | 11.1 SHORT PEAK | 16.0 PRIME | 3.5 CHWAR | 1.5 ADJ | 136.3 TOTAL |
42 | Chris Hoiles 1989—1998 | 23.5 CAREER | 22.1 LONG PEAK | 13.3 SHORT PEAK | 17.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 133.7 TOTAL |
43 | Tim McCarver 1959—1980 | 25.9 CAREER | 19.7 LONG PEAK | 11.7 SHORT PEAK | 15.9 PRIME | 11.4 CHWAR | 2.6 ADJ | 133.6 TOTAL |
44 | Terry Steinbach 1986—1999 | 27.5 CAREER | 21.5 LONG PEAK | 11.3 SHORT PEAK | 14.5 PRIME | 3.8 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 133.2 TOTAL |
45 | Darren Daulton 1983—1997 | 22.6 CAREER | 21.7 LONG PEAK | 14.7 SHORT PEAK | 17.0 PRIME | 5.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 132.4 TOTAL |
46 | Smoky Burgess 1949—1967 | 29.7 CAREER | 20.5 LONG PEAK | 9.5 SHORT PEAK | 13.0 PRIME | 3.3 CHWAR | -0.3 ADJ | 130.9 TOTAL |
47 | Ed Bailey 1953—1966 | 24.4 CAREER | 20.6 LONG PEAK | 10.9 SHORT PEAK | 15.6 PRIME | 1.9 CHWAR | 0.3 ADJ | 127.4 TOTAL |
48 | Mike Scioscia 1980—1992 | 24.9 CAREER | 20.3 LONG PEAK | 11.2 SHORT PEAK | 14.5 PRIME | 3.7 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 125.8 TOTAL |
49 | Butch Wynegar 1976—1988 | 24.4 CAREER | 21.0 LONG PEAK | 10.9 SHORT PEAK | 14.2 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 124.8 TOTAL |
50 | Walker Cooper 1940—1957 | 25.9 CAREER | 20.7 LONG PEAK | 10.6 SHORT PEAK | 12.8 PRIME | 9.1 CHWAR | -1.7 ADJ | 123.7 TOTAL |
51 | Sherm Lollar 1946—1963 | 26.5 CAREER | 19.3 LONG PEAK | 9.5 SHORT PEAK | 13.8 PRIME | 3.4 CHWAR | -0.8 ADJ | 123.5 TOTAL |
52 | Ray Schalk 1912—1929 | 27.5 CAREER | 18.1 LONG PEAK | 8.6 SHORT PEAK | 14.8 PRIME | 5.5 CHWAR | -5.5 ADJ | 120.0 TOTAL |
53 | Terry Kennedy 1978—1991 | 21.0 CAREER | 18.9 LONG PEAK | 11.6 SHORT PEAK | 15.7 PRIME | 0.6 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 119.2 TOTAL |
54 | Jonathan Lucroy 2010—2021 | 18.5 CAREER | 19.0 LONG PEAK | 13.5 SHORT PEAK | 17.4 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 118.4 TOTAL |
55 | Charles Johnson 1994—2005 | 21.1 CAREER | 18.9 LONG PEAK | 11.7 SHORT PEAK | 14.9 PRIME | 4.4 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 117.2 TOTAL |
56 | Bob Boone 1972—1990 | 25.3 CAREER | 18.6 LONG PEAK | 9.7 SHORT PEAK | 11.3 PRIME | 0.3 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 115.5 TOTAL |
57 | Mike Stanley 1986—2000 | 21.3 CAREER | 19.9 LONG PEAK | 12.3 SHORT PEAK | 14.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -2.8 ADJ | 115.4 TOTAL |
58 | Mike Napoli 2006—2017 | 25.6 CAREER | 22.1 LONG PEAK | 12.3 SHORT PEAK | 16.1 PRIME | 10.4 CHWAR | -20.1 ADJ | 115.3 TOTAL |
59 | Jason Varitek 1997—2011 | 22.7 CAREER | 17.6 LONG PEAK | 10.2 SHORT PEAK | 13.5 PRIME | 6.3 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 114.1 TOTAL |
60 | Johnny Bassler 1913—1927 | 20.9 CAREER | 19.5 LONG PEAK | 9.0 SHORT PEAK | 15.5 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -3.8 ADJ | 112.1 TOTAL |
61 | Ramon Hernandez 1999—2013 | 20.9 CAREER | 17.8 LONG PEAK | 10.0 SHORT PEAK | 14.1 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 111.1 TOTAL |
62 | Rick Dempsey 1969—1992 | 23.9 CAREER | 16.8 LONG PEAK | 8.7 SHORT PEAK | 11.7 PRIME | 3.9 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 110.8 TOTAL |
63 | Rick Ferrell 1929—1947 | 24.8 CAREER | 16.4 LONG PEAK | 7.6 SHORT PEAK | 13.8 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -3.3 ADJ | 110.1 TOTAL |
64 | John Stearns 1974—1984 | 19.0 CAREER | 18.9 LONG PEAK | 11.6 SHORT PEAK | 13.6 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 109.8 TOTAL |
65 | John Romano 1958—1967 | 18.9 CAREER | 18.1 LONG PEAK | 10.7 SHORT PEAK | 13.6 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 1.7 ADJ | 109.0 TOTAL |
66 | Matt Wieters 2009—2020 | 19.0 CAREER | 17.0 LONG PEAK | 11.7 SHORT PEAK | 14.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 108.0 TOTAL |
67 | John Roseboro 1957—1970 | 20.4 CAREER | 17.6 LONG PEAK | 9.3 SHORT PEAK | 12.3 PRIME | 7.9 CHWAR | 0.7 ADJ | 107.1 TOTAL |
68 | A.J. Pierzynski 1998—2016 | 22.7 CAREER | 17.2 LONG PEAK | 9.4 SHORT PEAK | 11.0 PRIME | 2.3 CHWAR | 0.1 ADJ | 107.0 TOTAL |
69 | Johnny Kling 1900—1913 | 23.5 CAREER | 18.1 LONG PEAK | 9.2 SHORT PEAK | 12.5 PRIME | 13.5 CHWAR | -7.4 ADJ | 106.9 TOTAL |
70 | Steve O'Neill 1911—1928 | 22.1 CAREER | 16.9 LONG PEAK | 9.9 SHORT PEAK | 13.8 PRIME | 4.8 CHWAR | -5.4 ADJ | 106.5 TOTAL |
71 | Chief Meyers 1909—1917 | 20.5 CAREER | 17.3 LONG PEAK | 9.7 SHORT PEAK | 14.7 PRIME | 13.7 CHWAR | -5.3 ADJ | 106.3 TOTAL |
72 | Spud Davis 1928—1945 | 20.7 CAREER | 17.5 LONG PEAK | 9.9 SHORT PEAK | 12.9 PRIME | 2.4 CHWAR | -2.9 ADJ | 105.2 TOTAL |
73 | Carlos Ruiz 2006—2017 | 17.5 CAREER | 16.3 LONG PEAK | 9.2 SHORT PEAK | 15.8 PRIME | 2.7 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 104.5 TOTAL |
74 | Kurt Suzuki 2007—2021 | 19.7 CAREER | 17.9 LONG PEAK | 9.8 SHORT PEAK | 11.2 PRIME | 0.4 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 102.8 TOTAL |
75 | Joe Ferguson 1970—1983 | 19.6 CAREER | 18.2 LONG PEAK | 12.2 SHORT PEAK | 9.1 PRIME | 3.5 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 101.8 TOTAL |
76 | Andy Seminick 1943—1957 | 18.5 CAREER | 16.1 LONG PEAK | 9.3 SHORT PEAK | 12.9 PRIME | 4.3 CHWAR | -0.9 ADJ | 99.8 TOTAL |
77 | Earl Battey 1955—1967 | 17.0 CAREER | 16.9 LONG PEAK | 9.6 SHORT PEAK | 12.5 PRIME | 3.2 CHWAR | 0.4 ADJ | 98.8 TOTAL |
78 | Ernie Whitt 1976—1991 | 17.0 CAREER | 16.9 LONG PEAK | 8.2 SHORT PEAK | 12.1 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 96.0 TOTAL |
79 | Quincy Trouppe 1930—1952 | 17.2 CAREER | 13.9 LONG PEAK | 9.8 SHORT PEAK | 13.0 PRIME | CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 94.5 TOTAL |
80 | Bob O'Farrell 1915—1935 | 18.0 CAREER | 14.1 LONG PEAK | 10.3 SHORT PEAK | 13.4 PRIME | 3.6 CHWAR | -3.9 ADJ | 94.3 TOTAL |
81 | Jody Davis 1981—1990 | 15.0 CAREER | 16.0 LONG PEAK | 9.0 SHORT PEAK | 13.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 93.6 TOTAL |
82 | Muddy Ruel 1915—1934 | 17.8 CAREER | 13.6 LONG PEAK | 8.1 SHORT PEAK | 13.9 PRIME | 4.8 CHWAR | -3.9 ADJ | 91.9 TOTAL |
83 | Alex Avila 2009—2021 | 17.1 CAREER | 15.5 LONG PEAK | 10.0 SHORT PEAK | 10.0 PRIME | 2.2 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 91.7 TOTAL |
84 | Miguel Montero 2006—2018 | 13.9 CAREER | 14.9 LONG PEAK | 11.2 SHORT PEAK | 13.1 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 91.3 TOTAL |
85 | Hank Gowdy 1910—1930 | 21.6 CAREER | 12.3 LONG PEAK | 6.3 SHORT PEAK | 11.6 PRIME | 5.5 CHWAR | -4.4 ADJ | 90.4 TOTAL |
86 | Paul LoDuca 1998—2008 | 13.4 CAREER | 14.0 LONG PEAK | 8.7 SHORT PEAK | 14.9 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 89.6 TOTAL |
87 | Steve Yeager 1972—1986 | 16.7 CAREER | 13.5 LONG PEAK | 7.5 SHORT PEAK | 11.2 PRIME | 7.3 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 88.7 TOTAL |
88 | Benito Santiago 1986—2005 | 17.8 CAREER | 12.1 LONG PEAK | 6.1 SHORT PEAK | 12.2 PRIME | 2.6 CHWAR | 1.0 ADJ | 88.5 TOTAL |
89 | Clay Dalrymple 1960—1971 | 15.3 CAREER | 13.5 LONG PEAK | 9.5 SHORT PEAK | 11.8 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.8 ADJ | 88.0 TOTAL |
90 | Don Slaught 1982—1997 | 18.3 CAREER | 13.6 LONG PEAK | 6.7 SHORT PEAK | 10.3 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 87.6 TOTAL |
91 | Brad Ausmus 1993—2010 | 15.8 CAREER | 14.3 LONG PEAK | 9.3 SHORT PEAK | 10.5 PRIME | 0.6 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 87.0 TOTAL |
92 | Bubbles Hargrave 1913—1930 | 14.7 CAREER | 15.9 LONG PEAK | 10.1 SHORT PEAK | 11.4 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -3.4 ADJ | 86.8 TOTAL |
93 | Yasmani Grandal 2012—2021 | 15.2 CAREER | 13.3 LONG PEAK | 7.3 SHORT PEAK | 12.0 PRIME | 5.5 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 85.4 TOTAL |
94 | Harry Danning 1933—1942 | 14.8 CAREER | 14.1 LONG PEAK | 9.0 SHORT PEAK | 11.6 PRIME | 1.3 CHWAR | -1.6 ADJ | 85.1 TOTAL |
95 | Hank Severeid 1911—1926 | 17.4 CAREER | 13.8 LONG PEAK | 6.7 SHORT PEAK | 11.7 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -4.2 ADJ | 85.0 TOTAL |
96 | Stan Lopata 1948—1960 | 13.5 CAREER | 14.3 LONG PEAK | 8.7 SHORT PEAK | 11.7 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | -0.2 ADJ | 83.9 TOTAL |
97 | Mike Lieberthal 1994—2007 | 14.2 CAREER | 13.7 LONG PEAK | 8.5 SHORT PEAK | 10.9 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 82.5 TOTAL |
98 | Ray Fosse 1967—1979 | 11.9 CAREER | 14.0 LONG PEAK | 9.9 SHORT PEAK | 11.7 PRIME | 3.1 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 82.0 TOTAL |
99 | Chris Iannetta 2006—2019 | 14.6 CAREER | 14.9 LONG PEAK | 8.5 SHORT PEAK | 8.9 PRIME | 0.0 CHWAR | 0.0 ADJ | 81.6 TOTAL |
100 | Sandy Alomar Jr. 1988—2007 | 13.9 CAREER | 13.4 LONG PEAK | 8.8 SHORT PEAK | 8.6 PRIME | 5.2 CHWAR | 1.5 ADJ | 79.1 TOTAL |