How close did Bill Clinton come to ending the baseball strike in 1995?

By Dan Holmes ♦ July 16, 2018

The 1994-95 strike was the longest labor stoppage in baseball history, the longest in sports history up to that time, and a black eye on the National Pastime. But even after the World Series was cancelled for the first time in nine decades, the strike was nearly halted the following February when Bill Clinton got involved in the dispute in rare action by a President.

At the center of the strike were three issues that deeply divided the players and the owners:

  1. The owners insisted the game needed a salary cap. A salary cap they said, was the only way small-market teams could compete against large-market teams with much deeper pockets.
  2. The players were still bitter over the collusion that occurred in the 1980s when owners secretly agreed to cooperate to keep player salaries lower.
  3. In 1992 the owners forced Faye Vincent to resign, and they did not replace him, leaving the game without a commissioner.

The 1994 season began without a new agreement in place and the owners quickly instituted a new agreement favorable to their positions. The players indicated that they would not accept the changes, such as the elimination of salary arbitration, the reduction of free agency eligibility from six to four years, and others. In July the MLB Players Association made it clear that unless the owners would bargain on a new agreement and abandon their insistence on a salary cap, they would walk off the job in August.

On August 12 the players went on strike, the two sides had little serious conversation for weeks. On September 8 the players made a last-ditch offer, which the owners rejected. On September 14, “interim” commissioner Bud Selig, still the principal owner of the Brewers, canceled the remainder of the season. For the first time since 1904, the World Series would not be played. No champion would be crowned in baseball in 1994.

Fast forward to January of 1995 and the two sides were no closer to an agreement. With spring training approaching, Clinton gave the players’ union and owners an ultimatum: come to an agreement by February 6. That deadline passed with no news, and efforts by Congress to legislate an agreement failed. On February 7, Clinton and Vice-President Al Gore summoned both sides to the White House. Clinton spent three hours trying to nudge the players and owners to an agreement.

How close did Clinton come? According to reports from those in the meeting, the President never got very close. The two sides agreed to keep salary arbitration and not change free agency, but the sticking point was how to divvy the profits from the game. The players wanted more money from gate receipts to go to smaller-market teams, the owners wanted a salary cap. Clinton recommended a cap and a tax on salaries for teams that exceeded the cap. The players were strident in their position to oppose anything that could keep salaries low. They were sure owners were not being honest about the financial condition of their teams.

Faced with empty clubhouses in spring training, the owners threatened to use replacement players, even put some of them in uniform. Some of the owners were very committed to using replacement players to start the 1995 season.

Eventually, a federal judge named Sonia Sotomayor (a future Supreme Court Justice) issued an injunction against the owners, upholding the MLBPA’s claim that the owners had used unfair labor practices by unilaterally implementing a salary cap and eliminating salary arbitration.

Clinton did not succeed in ending the 1994-95 baseball strike, but federal involvement in the dispute helped create the momentum that halted it. The bad sentiment created by the strike has led both players and owners to tread lightly when disputes arise. No labor stoppage has occurred in baseball since.


Tagged with: , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *