1958 Baseball Hall of Fame Election

266 total ballots (200 votes needed for election)

PLAYER	YoB	VOTES	VOTE %	ELECTED	PREV VOTES	+/- VOTES	+/- PCT
Max Carey	14	136	51.1	N	65	71	17.4
Edd Roush	18	112	42.1	N	91	21	-5.0
Red Ruffing	10	99	37.2	N	97	2	-13.0
Hack Wilson	13	94	35.3	N	74	20	-3.0
Sam Rice	11	90	33.8	N	45	45	10.5
Kiki Cuyler	10	90	33.8	N	55	35	5.3
Tony Lazzeri	12	80	30.1	N	64	16	-3.1
Luke Appling	4	77	28.9	N	0	0	0.0
Lefty Gomez	13	76	28.6	N	89	-13	-17.5
Burleigh Grimes	12	71	26.7	N	25	46	13.7
Red Faber	14	68	25.6	N	34	34	7.9
Lou Boudreau	2	64	24.1	N	2	62	23.0
Jim Bottomley	10	57	21.4	N	42	15	-0.3
Joe Medwick	3	50	18.8	N	0	0	0.0
Pepper Martin	11	46	17.3	N	0	0	0.0
Bucky Harris	9	45	16.9	N	0	0	0.0
Hank Gowdy	16	45	16.9	N	0	0	0.0
Dave Bancroft	14	43	16.2	N	0	0	0.0
Lloyd Waner	6	39	14.7	N	18	21	5.3
Waite Hoyt	13	37	13.9	N	37	0	-5.3
Chuck Klein	9	36	13.5	N	44	-8	-9.3
Johnny Vander Meer	2	35	13.2	N	3	32	11.6
Al Lopez	5	34	12.8	N	1	33	12.3
Earle Combs	12	34	12.8	N	0	0	0.0
Stan Coveleskie	5	34	12.8	N	0	0	0.0
Bucky Walters	5	33	12.4	N	5	28	9.8
Eppa Rixey	14	32	12.0	N	0	0	0.0
Leo Durocher	5	28	10.5	N	0	0	0.0
Lefty O'Doul	8	27	10.2	N	5	22	7.6
Charlie Grimm	10	26	9.8	N	0	0	0.0
Goose Goslin	7	26	9.8	N	0	0	0.0
Jimmy Dykes	9	26	9.8	N	0	0	0.0
Bobby Doerr	3	25	9.4	N	5	20	6.8
Heinie Manush	4	22	8.3	N	0	0	0.0
Jesse Haines	10	22	8.3	N	0	0	0.0
Nick Altrock	7	20	7.5	N	1	19	7.0
Billy Southworth	8	18	6.8	N	0	0	0.0
Freddie Fitzsimmons	5	16	6.0	N	0	0	0.0
Paul Derringer	6	15	5.6	N	12	3	-0.6
Dolf Luque	8	15	5.6	N	0	0	0.0
Earl Averill	5	14	5.3	N	0	0	0.0
Art Nehf	11	13	4.9	N	0	0	0.0
Babe Herman	11	13	4.9	N	0	0	0.0
Red Rolfe	6	13	4.9	N	0	0	0.0
Chick Hafey	10	12	4.5	N	0	0	0.0
Schoolboy Rowe	1	12	4.5	N	0	0	0.0
Terry Moore	3	12	4.5	N	0	0	0.0
Tommy Henrich	4	11	4.1	N	2	9	3.1
Tommy Bridges	2	11	4.1	N	3	8	2.6
Joe Gordon	3	11	4.1	N	4	7	2.1
Travis Jackson	10	11	4.1	N	14	-3	-3.1
Muddy Ruel	9	10	3.8	N	16	-6	-4.5
Steve O'Neill	7	10	3.8	N	0	0	0.0
Charlie Keller	3	9	3.4	N	2	7	2.3
Wes Ferrell	4	9	3.4	N	7	2	-0.2
Jack Quinn	3	9	3.4	N	0	0	0.0
Joe Judge	6	9	3.4	N	0	0	0.0
Wally Schang	4	8	3.0	N	1	7	2.5
Birdie Tebbetts	1	8	3.0	N	0	0	0.0
Glenn Wright	10	8	3.0	N	0	0	0.0
Eddie Rommel	7	7	2.6	N	1	6	2.3
Billy Herman	3	7	2.6	N	2	5	1.6
Howard Ehmke	8	7	2.6	N	0	0	0.0
Mel Harder	6	6	2.3	N	8	-2	-0.8
Arky Vaughan	5	6	2.3	N	9	-3	-2.4
Carl Mays	1	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Charlie Root	5	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Cy Williams	12	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Pete Reiser	1	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Pinky Higgins	3	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Stan Hack	6	6	2.3	N	0	0	0.0
Bob Meusel	10	5	1.9	N	1	4	1.4
Fielder Jones	4	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Firpo Marberry	3	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Frankie Crosetti	4	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Fred Lindstrom	3	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Joe Bush	1	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Joe Dugan	6	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Orval Grove	1	5	1.9	N	0	0	0.0
Max Bishop	3	4	1.5	N	1	3	1.0
Ernie Lombardi	4	4	1.5	N	8	-4	-2.6
Cookie Lavagetto	1	4	1.5	N	0	0	0.0
Dolph Camilli	3	4	1.5	N	0	0	0.0
George Uhle	2	4	1.5	N	0	0	0.0
Moe Berg	1	4	1.5	N	0	0	0.0
Urban Shocker	5	4	1.5	N	0	0	0.0
Mike Gonzalez	4	3	1.1	N	1	2	0.7
Tony Cuccinello	2	3	1.1	N	1	2	0.6
Luke Sewell	2	3	1.1	N	1	2	0.3
Lew Fonseca	4	3	1.1	N	2	1	0.1
Mort Cooper	2	3	1.1	N	2	1	0.1
Bill Doak	1	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Billy Werber	4	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Bob O'Farrell	2	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Chad Berry	2	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Frank Gustine	1	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Jimmie Wilson	10	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Willie Kamm	1	3	1.1	N	0	0	0.0
Wally Berger	2	2	0.8	N	1	1	0.2
Ossie Bluege	5	2	0.8	N	2	0	-0.3
Lon Warneke	2	2	0.8	N	2	0	-0.6
Bill Sherdel	8	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Cy Perkins	1	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Doc Cramer	2	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Earl Whitehill	2	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Freddy Leach	1	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
George Kelly	5	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Lee Meadows	1	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Marty McManus	1	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Ray Kremer	2	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Tommy Holmes	1	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Van Lingle Mungo	3	2	0.8	N	0	0	0.0
Mule Haas	3	1	0.4	N	1	0	-0.1
Alvin Crowder	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Bill Hallahan	3	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Billy Jurges	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Bing Miller	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Bubbles Hargrave	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Charley O'Leary	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Clyde Sukeforth	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Curt Davis	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Dick Bartell	3	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
George Case	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
George Grantham	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Gus Mancuso	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Gus Suhr	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Hal Schumacher	4	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Harry Danning	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Harry Walker	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Jack Scott	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Jimmy Austin	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Joe Sewell	6	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Johnny Mostil	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Jumbo Elliott	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Ken Keltner	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Ken Williams	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Larry Benton	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Monte Pearson	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Pep Young	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Ray Blades	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Red Kress	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Red Lucas	3	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Rick Ferrell	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Riggs Stephenson	2	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Rip Sewell	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Rube Walberg	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Sam Chapman	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Sparky Adams	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Tom Zachary	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Wally Moses	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Wally Pipp	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Warren Spahn	0	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0
Whit Wyatt	1	1	0.4	N	0	0	0.0