All-Time Catcher WAR Rankings

List of CATCHERS ranked by Wins Above Replacement. Which Catcher had the most Career WAR? Which Catcher had the most WAR in his seven best seasons, or three best seasons? We list Catchers by WAR in their best five consecutive seasons. Also find JAWS rankings. Sort these WAR tables in many ways.

CAREER WAR:
Career Wins Above Replacement.

WAR7:
Top 7 seasons, based on Wins Above Replacement.

WAR5C:
Best 5 consecutive seasons by Wins Above Replacement.

WAR3:
Top 3 seasons, based on Wins Above Replacement.

JAWS:
The average of Career WAR and WAR7. (Stat developed by Jay Jaffe)

FIRSTLASTHOFFROMTOWARWAR7WAR5CWAR3JAWS
JohnnyBenchY1967198375.247.232.723.961.2
GaryCarterY1974199270.148.235.823.159.2
JoshGibsonY1930194672.856.844.230.564.8
CarltonFiskY1969199368.437.723.220.353.1
IvanRodriguezY1991201168.739.630.319.354.2
YogiBerraY1946196559.536.827.517.448.2
JoeMauerN2004201855.339.028.919.547.2
BusterPoseyN2009202144.936.729.218.840.8
ThurmanMunsonN1969197946.037.027.019.341.5
JoeTorreN1960197757.637.225.717.847.4
TedSimmonsY1968198850.334.822.916.242.6
BillDickeyY1928194657.335.926.318.146.6
RoyCampanellaY1937195735.634.326.918.935.0
MikePiazzaY1992200759.642.230.921.950.9
BillFreehanN1961197644.733.722.518.339.2
JorgePosadaN1995201142.732.923.216.837.8
JasonKendallN1996201041.730.420.014.636.1
JimSundbergN1974198940.528.621.314.334.6
YadierMolinaN2004202242.228.722.416.535.5
GeneTenaceN1969198346.834.925.416.340.9
MickeyCochraneY1925193749.136.227.017.642.7
GabbyHartnettY1922194156.931.020.615.144.0
LanceParrishN1977199539.528.419.514.334.0
DarrellPorterN1971198740.929.018.315.735.0
RussellMartinN2006201938.826.716.715.032.8
J.T.RealmutoN2014202333.329.620.315.531.5
BrianMcCannN2005201931.924.517.613.428.2
SalvadorPerezN2011202333.024.115.213.128.6
TonyPenaN1980199724.724.720.713.824.7
WallySchangN1913193147.925.217.512.336.6
BizMackeyY1920194748.329.920.416.539.1
ElstonHowardN1955196827.126.620.716.026.9
VictorMartinezN2002201831.928.317.115.030.1
ErnieLombardiY1931194739.525.017.712.332.3
RogerBresnahanY1897191542.130.522.916.036.3
DelCrandallN1949196628.224.617.313.626.4
JavyLopezN1992200629.724.815.315.127.3
MickeyTettletonN1984199729.424.720.714.927.1
BobBooneN1972199027.420.212.210.523.8
MannySanguillenN1967198027.626.418.913.727.0
TimMcCarverN1959198028.321.517.312.824.9
TerrySteinbachN1986199928.021.515.610.924.8
TomHallerN1961197229.324.017.612.226.7
RaySchalkY1912192933.022.018.010.527.5
ShermLollarN1946196330.121.915.710.826.0
MikeSciosciaN1980199226.121.715.712.123.9
SmokyBurgessN1949196733.323.014.610.628.2
ButchWynegarN1976198826.522.815.411.824.7
DarrenDaultonN1983199723.022.218.315.822.6
A.J.PierzynskiN1998201623.818.011.59.920.9
RickFerrellY1929194729.819.716.69.124.8
LouisSantopY1910192640.325.816.014.133.1
ChrisHoilesN1989199823.522.318.613.322.9
WalkerCooperN1940195727.323.015.012.425.2
EdBaileyN1953196627.223.017.412.225.1
WillsonContrerasN2016202324.223.315.311.923.8
TerryKennedyN1978199121.619.317.011.620.5
JasonVaritekN1997201124.218.714.410.921.5
MikeNapoliN2006201726.322.716.612.724.5
RickDempseyN1969199225.117.412.79.421.3
RamonHernandezN1999201322.118.814.910.620.5
CharlesJohnsonN1994200522.620.416.112.621.5
JonathanLucroyN2010202117.719.217.613.718.5
SteveO'NeillN1911192826.120.616.812.123.4
JohnRoseboroN1957197022.519.413.610.321.0
KurtSuzukiN2007202219.518.311.410.018.9
JohnnyKlingN1900191329.022.415.511.425.7
BenitoSantiagoN1986200527.418.613.19.423.0
MattWietersN2009202018.317.314.511.917.8
MikeStanleyN1986200020.919.415.411.320.2
BradAusmusN1993201016.515.011.29.715.8
SpudDavisN1928194523.021.215.612.022.1
CarlosRuizN2006201722.520.916.211.821.7
AndySeminickN1943195721.518.715.010.820.1
JohnnyBasslerN1913192721.319.718.810.920.5
YanGomesN2012202319.317.99.711.018.6
ChiefMeyersN1909191725.221.318.111.923.3
JohnRomanoN1958196720.920.015.011.820.5
JohnStearnsN1974198419.719.514.712.519.6
MuddyRuelN1915193420.516.416.89.818.5
EarlBatteyN1955196718.818.713.910.618.8
BobO'FarrellN1915193521.317.116.212.419.2
ErnieWhittN1976199118.318.313.18.918.3
QuincyTrouppeN1930195221.117.016.012.019.1
JoeFergusonN1970198321.019.79.913.220.4
HankGowdyN1910193023.713.714.17.118.7
JodyDavisN1981199015.816.914.49.816.4
MiguelMonteroN2006201814.315.313.411.514.8
SteveYeagerN1972198617.914.712.28.116.3
DonSlaughtN1982199719.314.711.17.217.0
HankSevereidN1911192618.616.714.28.117.7
AlexAvilaN2009202116.815.510.210.216.2
PaulLoDucaN1998200817.918.716.011.618.3
JohnnyEdwardsN1961197414.815.410.19.115.1
MikeLieberthalN1994200715.314.711.79.115.0
ClayDalrympleN1960197116.814.813.010.515.8
SandyAlomar Jr.N1988200713.713.29.28.413.5
AlLopezN1928194717.711.99.26.114.8
ChrisIannettaN2006201915.015.39.18.715.2
JerryGroteN1963198115.114.28.98.514.7
YasmaniGrandalN2012202319.619.212.110.519.4
DanWilsonN1992200513.014.210.29.613.6
BubblesHargraveN1913193016.417.913.912.317.2
HarryDanningN1933194214.715.713.910.715.2
MikeMacfarlaneN1987199914.713.710.18.714.2
RayFosseN1967197912.915.212.710.714.1
MiltMayN1970198416.513.08.57.414.8
FrankSnyderN1912192717.514.59.09.216.0
RandyHundleyN1964197711.613.412.59.912.5
StanLopataN1948196015.316.213.39.915.8
GusTriandosN1953196514.114.211.88.914.2
GreggZaunN1995201013.713.310.78.313.5
IveyWingoN1911192917.912.012.06.815.0
RichGedmanN198019929.713.511.412.011.6
RonHasseyN1978199114.713.88.78.514.3
FrankieHayesN1933194710.318.69.37.014.5
BoDiazN1977198911.513.89.78.312.7
GeorgeGibsonN1905191814.815.29.69.115.0
MikeHeathN1978199113.412.58.27.613.0
ToddHundleyN1990200310.815.512.811.313.2
BobBrenlyN1981198912.713.912.310.213.3
PhilMasiN1939195214.313.710.88.114.0
BrianHarperN1979199512.313.712.38.013.0
ShantyHoganN1925193714.914.310.89.314.6
BengieMolinaN1998201010.710.87.66.010.8
AlanAshbyN1973198911.110.15.66.210.6
GusMancusoN1928194510.412.18.96.511.3
RayMuellerN1935195111.511.711.09.411.6
CliffJohnsonN1972198616.214.47.78.815.3
JimmieWilsonN192319409.28.78.05.59.0
DaveValleN1984199610.010.47.97.010.2
RickCeroneN197519928.010.54.57.29.3
JasonLaRueN199920108.99.39.17.29.1
BuddyRosarN193919519.910.510.05.810.2
JimHeganN194119603.75.65.03.54.7
JoeAzcueN196019728.510.77.18.19.6
CharlieMooreN1973198710.39.47.45.29.9
BillRaridenN190919208.710.19.67.99.4
ClydeMcCulloughN194019569.09.95.86.89.5
AdleyRutschmanN202220239.69.59.69.59.6
RyanDoumitN200520149.210.07.86.69.6
DaveNilssonN1992199910.610.38.87.510.5
DamianMillerN199720079.08.46.14.98.7
LukeSewellN192119423.86.63.73.75.2
RollieHemsleyN192819473.78.03.55.15.8
JoeGirardiN198920035.77.13.13.86.1
MiguelOlivoN200220147.98.55.35.38.2
BruceBenedictN197819897.38.87.36.58.0
BillBergenN19011911-13.5-6.2-2.0-1.9-9.9