All-Time Catcher WAR Rankings

WAR
Career Wins Above Replacement.

WAR7
Top 7 seasons, based on Wins Above Replacement.

WAR5C
Best 5 consecutive seasons by Wins Above Replacement.

WAR3
Top 3 seasons, based on Wins Above Replacement.

JAWS
The average of Career WAR and WAR7. (Stat developed by Jay Jaffe)

NAMEHOFWARWAR7WAR5CWAR3JAWS
Johnny BenchY75.247.232.723.961.2
Gary CarterY70.148.235.823.159.2
Mike PiazzaY59.642.230.921.950.9
Carlton FiskY68.437.723.220.353.1
Yogi BerraY59.536.827.517.448.2
Thurman Munson46.037.027.019.341.5
Roy CampanellaY35.634.326.918.935.0
Mickey CochraneY49.136.227.017.642.7
Joe Mauer55.339.028.919.547.2
Ivan RodriguezY68.739.630.319.354.2
Bill DickeyY57.335.926.318.146.6
Buster Posey44.237.229.219.040.7
Joe Torre57.637.225.717.847.4
Ted SimmonsY50.334.822.916.242.6
Bill Freehan44.733.722.518.339.2
Gene Tenace46.834.925.416.340.9
Gabby HartnettY56.931.020.615.144.0
Jorge Posada42.732.923.216.837.8
Yadier Molina41.528.722.416.535.1
Jim Sundberg40.528.621.314.334.6
Jason Kendall41.730.420.014.636.1
Darrell Porter40.929.018.315.735.0
Roger BresnahanY42.130.522.916.036.3
Lance Parrish39.528.419.514.334.0
Wally Schang47.925.217.512.336.6
Russell Martin38.826.716.715.032.8
Elston Howard27.126.620.716.026.9
Ernie LombardiY39.525.017.712.332.3
Brian McCann31.924.517.613.428.2
Victor Martinez31.928.317.115.030.1
Mickey Tettleton29.424.720.714.927.1
Manny Sanguillen27.626.418.913.727.0
Del Crandall28.224.617.313.626.4
Tony Pena24.724.720.713.824.7
Javy Lopez29.724.815.315.127.3
Tom Haller29.324.017.612.226.7
Salvador Perez27.521.815.911.024.7
Smoky Burgess33.323.014.610.628.2
Tim McCarver28.321.517.312.824.9
Darren Daulton23.022.218.315.822.6
Chris Hoiles23.522.318.613.322.9
Terry Steinbach28.021.515.610.924.8
Ray SchalkY33.022.018.010.527.5
J.T. Realmuto22.422.518.313.522.5
Walker Cooper27.323.015.012.425.2
Ed Bailey27.223.017.412.225.1
Sherm Lollar30.121.915.710.826.0
Mike Scioscia26.121.715.712.123.9
Butch Wynegar26.522.815.411.824.7
Johnny Bassler21.319.718.810.920.5
Chief Meyers25.221.318.111.923.3
Bob Boone27.420.212.210.523.8
Mike Napoli26.322.716.612.724.5
Rick FerrellY29.819.716.69.124.8
Johnny Kling29.022.415.511.425.7
Steve O'Neill26.120.616.812.123.4
Charles Johnson22.620.416.112.621.5
Mike Stanley20.919.415.411.320.2
Spud Davis23.021.215.612.022.1
Carlos Ruiz22.520.916.211.821.7
Jason Varitek24.218.714.410.921.5
Jonathan Lucroy17.719.217.613.718.5
Terry Kennedy21.619.317.011.620.5
Rick Dempsey25.117.412.79.421.3
John Romano20.920.015.011.820.5
John Stearns19.719.514.712.519.6
Ramon Hernandez22.118.814.910.620.5
John Roseboro22.519.413.610.321.0
Andy Seminick21.518.715.010.820.1
A.J. Pierzynski23.818.011.59.920.9
Bob O'Farrell21.317.116.212.419.2
Matt Wieters18.317.314.511.917.8
Joe Ferguson21.019.79.913.220.4
Muddy Ruel20.516.416.89.818.5
Earl Battey18.818.713.910.618.8
Hank Gowdy23.713.714.17.118.7
Kurt Suzuki19.718.311.410.019.0
Benito Santiago27.418.613.19.423.0
Bubbles Hargrave16.417.913.912.317.2
Ernie Whitt18.318.313.18.918.3
Jody Davis15.816.914.49.816.4
Hank Severeid18.616.714.28.117.7
Harry Danning14.715.713.910.715.2
Clay Dalrymple16.814.813.010.515.8
Paul LoDuca17.918.716.011.618.3
Steve Yeager17.914.712.28.116.3
Stan Lopata15.316.213.39.915.8
Miguel Montero14.315.313.411.514.8
Don Slaught19.314.711.17.217.0
Alex Avila16.815.510.210.216.2
Brad Ausmus16.515.011.29.715.8
Ray Fosse12.915.212.710.714.1
Mike Lieberthal15.314.711.79.115.0
Johnny Edwards14.815.410.19.115.1
Yasmani Grandal19.815.512.18.517.7
Frank Snyder17.514.59.09.216.0
Gus Triandos14.114.211.88.914.2
Sandy Alomar Jr.13.713.29.28.413.5
Bob Brenly12.713.912.310.213.3
Mike Macfarlane14.713.710.18.714.2
Chris Iannetta15.015.39.18.715.2
Ivey Wingo17.912.012.06.815.0
Milt May16.513.08.57.414.8
Jerry Grote15.114.28.98.514.7
Brian Harper12.313.712.38.013.0
Randy Hundley11.613.412.59.912.5
Shanty Hogan14.914.310.89.314.6
Cliff Johnson16.214.47.78.815.3
Ron Hassey14.713.88.78.514.3
Dan Wilson13.014.210.29.613.6
Rich Gedman9.713.511.412.011.6
Gregg Zaun13.713.310.78.313.5
Phil Masi14.313.710.88.114.0
George Gibson14.815.29.69.115.0
Bo Diaz11.513.89.78.312.7
Frankie Hayes10.318.69.37.014.5
Al Lopez17.711.99.26.114.8
Todd Hundley10.815.512.811.313.2
Mike Heath13.412.58.27.613.0
Ray Mueller11.511.711.09.411.6
Baseball Egg