20 Greatest St. Louis Cardinals

St louis cardinals war leaders
20

Red Schoendienst

If anyone bled Cardinal red it was Schoendienst, who wore a St. Louis uniform for 67 years as a player, coach, and manager. In all, he spent 74 years in uniform, which is most likely a record. Was Schoendienst worthy of a Hall of Fame plaque as a player? For the first 13 years of his career he was an everyday second baseman on good teams and he did some nice things. As a rookie he led the league in stolen bases. One year he led the National League in doubles. He had 200 hits when he was 34 years old, the same season he was traded to the Braves and sparked them to the pennant. He earned MVP votes in six of his 14 full seasons and his teams won three pennants and two World Series titles.
19

Bob Caruthers

18

Johnny Mize

Mize was ahead of his time in the science of hitting. He kept a trunk filled with bats in his locker, each of them of varying weights. He used the lighter bats against hard throwers and the heavier ones against soft tossers. It worked: Big Jawn had the second-most home runs in National League history when he played his last game in that league in 1949.
17

Ray Lankford

Lankford is the only player to have at least 200 stolen bases and home runs for the Cardinals. He had his best season at age 31 and declined rapidly.
16

Jim Edmonds

“Jim’s a show. I’ve seen [him] make a dozen plays where you just say ‘Wow, that’s amazing.’ He has such a beautiful swing, I’d get jealous of it, and in pressure-packed situations he seems so relaxed. He has that flair.” — teammate Tim Salmon
15

Harry Brecheen

14

Joe Medwick

Once, Chicago Cubs manager Charley Grimm was going over the St. Louis lineup with his starting pitcher prior to a game. When they came to Medwick, the pitcher asked Grimm how he should pitch him. Grimm replied, “Just throw the ball and back up third base.”
13

Yadier Molina

Not as good as everyone thinks he was, but still an ecellent defensive catcher who liked to wear lots of eyeblack. He was basically Brad Ausmus with tattoos.
12

Lou Brock

“Brock is worth one run a game, and in these days of low-octane scoring, one run is like an avalanche.” — teammate Bill White
11

Dizzy Dean

10

Curt Flood

9

Ted Simmons

Simmons was a hippy. He attended the University of Michigan in the late 1960s, and at that time Ann Arbor was one of the hotbeds of the swelling anti-establishment movement. Simmons was thoughtful and quickly grasped the political importance of that era. He grew his hair long, he participated in marches, he joined demonstrations. After he became a professional ballplayer with St. Louis, he was outspoken in his opposition to the Vietnam War and he criticized Richard Nixon. That didn’t make him popular with many people, in fact it made him a pariah. The media was far more conservative at that time than it is now, the front office hated hippies, and they felt that anyone who criticized anything was a radical leftist.
8

Adam Wainwright

7

Enos Slaughter

In 1942 when he was 26 years old, Slaughter helped lead the Cardinals to their first pennant in eight years. He did it all, hitting .318 with a .412 on-base percentage, while leading the league in total bases, hits, and triples. He finished second to teammate Mort Cooper in MVP voting, but the award should have been his.
6

Ken Boyer

“Ken was always my idol, and he was the greatest. I always [got to] play in the World Series, though. I know this meant a lot to him. I’m happy for him.” — brother Clete Boyer, after Ken and the Cardinals defeated his Yankees in the 1964 World Series
5

Ozzie Smith

“The guy at shortstop makes all the difference. He plays hard all the time. There’s nothing greater than Ozzie diving for a ball and throwing someone out.” — Bruce Sutter
4

Albert Pujols

Pujols became the first Cardinal rookie in 46 years to make the All-Star team. He was named Rookie of the Year and finished fourth in MVP voting. It was the first of 11 straight seasons Pujols finished in the top ten. He won the MVP three times and probably should have won it five straight years. Had others not cheated, Pujols could have won as many as seven MVP awards. .
3

Bob Gibson

2

Rogers Hornsby

The struggle against a pitcher was Hornsby’s refuge. He stood deep in the box, so far back that contemporaries took note of it. Hornsby said it allowed him to wait on the breaking pitch and hit it after the break. He held his bat high, higher than the other three great hitters of his time, Cobb, Shoeless Joe, and Babe Ruth. Like Henry Aaron years later, Roger liked to twist his hands on the handle of the bat as he waited for the pitch. He was a dangerous pull hitter, once telling his son Billy, who briefly tried to reach the majors, “No pitcher could throw an inside fastball past me…no one.”
1

Stan Musial

Musial had 3,266 more at-bats than Ted Williams, yet he struck out 13 fewer times. He credited his ability to make contact to being poor. “I learned to hit with a broomstick and a ball of tape,” he said. Another fact about Musial: as of 2025, Musial still ranks third all-time in total bases, behind only Henry Aaron and Albert Pujols.