Is Buster Posey a Hall of Famer?

The 2021 season will be the last of Buster Posey’s career. The Giants’ catcher, after a resurgent year, is hanging up his chest protector after 12 years, all with San Francisco.

Posey has tremendous credentials and accolades on his record, and he was a central figure in not one, not, two, but three World Series titles. He’s the greatest catcher in the history of the Giants, and the best all-around catcher we’ve had in baseball in the 21st century.

But now that Posey is heading into a new phase of his life, the question comes to mind: is Buster a Hall of Famer?

It’s not an easy question to find an answer to. It requires a deep dive.

First, we’ll look at how Posey matches up against the greatest catchers of all-time in Wins Above Replacement, as well as against other notable catchers of his era and the last 50 years.

The table below shows career WAR, WAR7 (which measures long peak), WAR3 (short peak), JAWS (an average of career and long peak), and WAR5C (our measurement of the five best consecutive seasons by the player).

Catcher Wins Above Replacement Comparison

NAMEWARWAR7WAR5CWAR3JAWS
Buster Posey44.936.729.218.840.8
Johnny Bench75.247.232.723.961.2
Gary Carter70.148.235.823.159.2
Mike Piazza59.642.230.921.950.9
Roy Campanella35.634.326.918.935.0
Joe Mauer55.339.028.919.547.2
Carlton Fisk68.437.723.220.353.1
Pudge Rodriguez68.739.630.319.354.2
Thurman Munson46.037.027.019.313.4
Bill Freehan44.733.722.518.339.2
Jorge Posada42.732.923.216.837.8
Ted Simmons50.334.822.916.242.6
Yadier Molina42.128.722.416.535.4

Because Posey is hanging up his cleats after only 12 seasons, his career numbers are not up to the standards of the great catchers. But there’s still a level of Hall of Famers he might fit into: the next tier of catchers that includes Mickey Cochrane and Roy Campanella.

Neither Campanella nor Cochrane played long in the white major leagues. Campy started late due to the color barrier, and was injured in a car accident and lost his career at the age of 35. Cochrane suffered a nearly fatal beaning that ended his playing career at the age of 34. He was winding down as a player, but his career numbers, as seen in the table above, are very similar to those of Posey.

Posey had a higher long and short peak, and a batter prime than Cochrane, but he falls about 5 WAR short of Mickey’s career WAR.

Career value is important, but perhaps less important for a catcher who had a strong peak. But there are other factors to consider: like winning.

Most World Series Titles by a Starting Catcher

  • Yogi Berra … 8
  • Bill Dickey … 7
  • Elston Howard … 3
  • Jorge Posada … 4
  • Buster Posey … 3
  • Mickey Cochrane … 3
  • Johnny Roseboro … 3

Posey was typically the #3 hitter for the Giants when they won championships in 2010, 2012, and again in 2014. But that’s not all. He also ranks in the top 15 on our list of the Greatest Catchers of All-Time.

Only three catchers have won a Rookie of the Year Award and a Most Valuable Player Award: Johnny Bench, Thurman Munson, and Posey.

Here’s another tidbit: Buster Posey is the only catcher to win Rookie of the Year, an MVP< and a batting title in his career. Posey led the National League in batting in 2012 with a .336 average. That was his best season: he topped .300/.400/.500 in batting/on-base/slugging, and also hit 24 homers and had 103 runs batted in.

In 2021, he came back after choosing to sit out the 2020 pandemic year and batted .304 with a stellar .390 on-base percentage, .499 slugging, and 18 home runs. He was still a very valuable offensive player, posting an OPS+ of 140. His career batting average sits at .302 with exactly 1,500 hits.

A seven-time All-Star, Gold Glove winner, and Silver Slugger, Posey has practically ever honor you can achieve in baseball. Will it be enough to garner a Hall of Fame nod from voters who made Mike Piazza wait until his fourth appearance on the ballot to be elected? Or forced Carlton Fisk(!) to wait two tries to get a plaque, or who somehow took SIX BALLOTS to elect the great Gary Carter?

What do you think about Posey’s Hall of Fame credentials? Tell us in the comments section below.

Dan Holmes

Dan Holmes

Dan Holmes is the author of three books about baseball, including Ty Cobb: A Biography. He formerly worked for the National Baseball Hall of Fame, and Major League Baseball Advanced Media. He lives in Michigan where he writes, runs, and enjoys a good orange soda now and again.

Leave a Response

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.