When Hall of Famers made their big league debut

share on:

When Juan Marichal stepped on the mound for the first time as a big leaguer, it was the first major league game he had ever seen. Nine innings later, he completed one of the most spectacular debuts in baseball history, and launched a career that would land him in Cooperstown.

Outstanding Mound Debuts

Marichal shrugged off the first-game jitters on July 19, 1960, when he made his major league debut against the Phillies in Candlestick Park. Leading the Pacific Coast League in strikeouts, the 22-year old right-hander was called to the majors a few weeks after Tom Sheehan replaced Bill Rigney as Giants’ manager. Marichal, nicknamed the “Dominican Dandy,” baffled Philadelphia batters, setting down the first 19 men he faced. His perfect game was spoiled when an error was made behind him in the 7th inning, and Clay Dalrymple’s pinch-hit single left Marichal four outs shy of pitching a no-hitter in his first game. Marichal finished the game with a one-hitter, striking out 12 Phillies in a 2-0 victory that signaled his arrival on the major league scene. Sheehan raved, “Marichal isn’t afraid to put the ball over the plate. He has more pitching sense than anybody I’ve seen.” That’s why Marichal rates among baseball’s greatest pitchers.

When Dizzy Dean made his major league debut, he denied the opposing pitcher $1,000 while pitching in ill-fitting borrowed shoes. The 20-year old, who honed his pitching skills by hurling rocks at birds in Arkansas, emerged in grand fashion on September 28, 1930, the day after the St. Louis Cardinals had wrapped up the National League pennant, and the final day of the season. Larry French, the Pirates’ starter, was anxious to end his season with a win, since he was stuck on 17 victories, and his contract called for a $1,000 bonus if he won 18 games. French may have already been counting the money when he learned he’d be facing a fresh rookie. But Dean, a hard throwing right-hander, had different plans. Wearing shoes he borrowed from teammate Burleigh Grimes, who was five inches shorter, Dean threw a complete game, three-hit victory over Pittsburgh, collected a single and stole home to provide the winning run! After Dean’s stellar performance, Cardinals’ manager Gabby Street gave him a supreme compliment, calling him “another Walter Johnson.” Dean, showing the brashness that would become his trademark, moaned to reporters after the game, “Those bums got three hits off’n me.”

Walter Johnson made his first big league appearance for the Senators on August 2, 1907, and drew the assignment of facing the hard-hitting Tigers. Detroit attacked Johnson’s psyche before the game started. Several players razzed Johnson as he warmed up, calling him a “hayseed” and a “country bumpkin.” The first batter to step in against Johnson was Tigers’ leadoff man Davy Jones, who recalled that the first pitch Johnson delivered was “the fastest ball I ever saw.” Johnson retired the side in the first and then faced Ty Cobb to lead off the second frame. Cobb tested the youngster immediately, dragging the first pitch toward first for a perfectly placed bunt single. Johnson took the loss 3-2, but it was just the first of many battles between Johnson and Cobb in the years to come. Johnson went on to become the greatest pitcher in baseball history.

Robin Roberts was famous even before he made his major league debut. A star baseball and basketball player at Michigan State University, the future Hall of Fame pitcher signed a $25,000 bonus contract with the Phillies in 1948. On June 18, the 21-year old debuted in Philadelphia against the Pirates. He delivered on his promise, hurling eight innings of five-hit ball before leaving for a pinch-hitter.

Giving little indication of his future as the game’s greatest slugger, Babe Ruth debuted as a promising young left-handed pitcher for the Red Sox, on July 11, 1914. Facing the Highlanders (later known as the Yankees), Ruth pitched the Sox to an 11-5 win, delivering a double to help his cause.

The man who would win more games than any other pitcher in baseball history made his debut on August 6, 1890, for the Cleveland Spiders of the National League. Cy Young, carrying the nickname “The Canton Cyclone,” stymied the Chicago Colts (precursor of the Cubs) on three harmless singles, shutting down future Hall of Famer Cap Anson’s team, 8-1.

Hall of Fame Sluggers in their MLB Debuts

Hitters have made a big splash in their debuts as well. One of the finest debuts in history was turned in by Willie McCovey on July 30, 1959, in San Francisco. McCovey was a heralded prospect, having paced the Pacific Coast League with a .377 average and 28 homers prior to his call-up. On that day he hit third in the Giants’ lineup, sandwiched between Willie Mays and Orlando Cepeda. The three future Hall of Famers helped the team to a 7-2 win, with McCovey lacing four hits, including two triples. “Big Mac” scored three runs and drove in two, playing first base while Cepeda moved to third.

Earl Averill blasted a home run in his first major league at-bat, off Detroit’s Earl Whitehill on April 16, 1929, in Cleveland. Averill became the first player to hit a homer in his first at-bat and later earn induction to Cooperstown. Reliever Hoyt Wilhelm matched that feat, but he did it four days after his major league debut as a pitcher, on April 23, 1952. It was the only home run of Wilhelm’s career.

Batting third in a lineup that featured future Hall of Famers Lou Gehrig, Bill Dickey, Tony Lazzeri and Lefty Gomez, young Joe DiMaggio made his debut on May 3, 1936, in Yankee Stadium. A heralded prospect whose debut had been delayed by an injury for several weeks, DiMaggio failed to disappoint, slamming a triple and two singles off St. Louis Browns’ pitching. DiMaggio wore uniform #9 and played left field in his first game, with Ben Chapman in center. His arrival signaled the dawn of a new era in Yankee history, the transition from the Ruth/Gehrig Yankees, to the DiMaggio Yankees. It also sparked a new interest in baseball by the Italian population of New York City. The day after DiMaggio’s debut, the New York Post reported that “an astonishing portion of the crowd was composed of strangers to the sport – mostly Italians – who did not even know the stadium subway station.”

In his debut, Padres’ outfielder Dave Winfield collected his first major league hit the hard way. He slid head first into the bag for a single off Astros’ lefty Jerry Reuss to lead off the ninth inning, on June 19, 1973, in San Diego.

When Honus Wagner came to the National League to play for the Louisville Colonels in the middle of the 1897 season, he was already regarded as one of the finest players in the country, having starred in the American Association. Wagner hit third for the Colonels’ on July 19, collecting a single and making several fine plays in the field. The Louisville Commercial dubbed him “Count Hans Von Wagner,” and boasted that Wagner “throws like a shot and is remarkably fast.”

When Hall of Famers Debut in the same Game

Interesting intersections also occur in the debuts of Hall of Famers. One of the most famous debuts occurred in Philadelphia on April 14, 1925, when two future Hall of Famers took their first steps toward Cooperstown on the same team. Connie Mack wrote the names of Lefty Grove and Mickey Cochrane in his lineup that day for the first time, Grove as the starting pitcher, and Cochrane coming in as a defensive replacement behind the plate. Grove, labeled a “$100,000 Beauty” because of the steep price Mack paid for the left-hander, pitched into the fourth inning, and left in a 6-0 hole. Cochrane entered the game in the eighth inning, and ended up delivering a single in the bottom of the 10th frame that set up the A’s winning score. Mack’s “$150,000 battery” had made their debut.

Less than three weeks later, Jimmie Foxx made his big league debut, pinch-hitting for Grove (who was also called “Groves” in many box scores early in his career), and drawing a walk. The newspapers referred to the future Hall of Fame slugger as “James Fox.”

Only one date in history saw as many as three future Hall of Famers make their major league debuts. On Opening Day of the 1956 season, April 17, Frank Robinson debuted for the Reds in Cincinnati, Don Drysdale debuted for the Dodgers in Brooklyn, and Luis Aparicio did the same for the White Sox in Chicago. Aparicio collected a hit off Bob Lemon, and Robinson stroked two hits in his first look.

In Hank Aaron’s major league debut on April 13, 1954, Opening Day in Cincinnati, future Hall of Fame third baseman Eddie Mathews blasted two home runs. It was the first two of the record 863 homers the pair would hit as teammates.

In the game that saw pitcher and future Hall of Fame manager Tommy Lasorda debut for the Brooklyn Dodgers, on August 5, 1954, Stan Musial had one of the greatest games of his career, hitting two homers and driving in seven runs for the Cardinals. Lasorda faced Musial in the seventh inning and limited him to a sacrifice fly.

President Franklin D. Roosevelt attended the first major league game ever played by future Hall of Fame shortstop Phil Rizzuto, on Opening Day in Washington D.C., April 14, 1941. “Scooter” drew a walk and turned two double plays in the field for the Yankees.

The first batter versus pitcher matchup for some Hall of Famers was noteworthy. Twenty-year old Ted Williams debuted in Yankee Stadium on April 20, 1939, lining a double off Red Ruffing.

Sandy Koufax’s first strikeout victim in the major leagues was Hank Aaron. Koufax came on in relief for the Brooklyn Dodgers on June 24, 1955, in Milwaukee’s County Stadium, pitching two shutout innings and fanning two. The first strikeout victim of Gaylord Perry’s career was Frank Robinson.

The first two batters faced by Nolan Ryan in his career were Eddie Mathews and Hank Aaron, on September 11, 1966. Neither of them struck out against Ryan, not that day at least.

Braves’ pitcher Warren Spahn, who was a WWII hero, was tested immediately in his MLB debut. Pitching against the New York Giants on April 19, 1942, the future Hall of Fame southpaw faced formidable opposition from the outset. The first two batters Spahn faced as a major league pitcher were Mel Ott and Johnny Mize, both of whom earned plaques in Cooperstown. Spahn walked Ott and retired Mize on a grounder to first base.

Hall of Fame Managers Who Debuted as Players

Speaking of Mize, he played a role in the debut of another future Hall of Famer. Walter Alston reached Cooperstown on his managerial record, but he had a very interesting major league debut as a player. Late in the 1936 season, on September 27, Alston, a prospect with the St. Louis Cardinals, got his first and only taste of major league action when Mize was ejected for arguing with the first base umpire in the seventh inning. In his only major league at-bat, Alston struck out against Cubs’ right-hander Lon Warneke. Eighteen years later, Alston was back in the big leagues, managing the Brooklyn Dodgers.

Richie Ashburn hit second in the Phillies order behind Sparky Anderson in Sparky’s major league debut, on April 10, 1959, while fellow future Hall of Famer Robin Roberts was on the mound for the Phillies. Roberts earned the win when Anderson drove in the deciding run in the 8th frame.

Future Hall of Famers Unnoticed on Day One in the Big Leagues

A few Hall of Famers made auspicious debuts, barely recognizable in the box scores, yet significant nonetheless. Ozzie Smith made his debut on April 7, 1978, playing three innings at shortstop and grounding out in his only at-bat against San Francisco’s John Montefusco. Smith was removed for a pinch-hitter, but his glove was too valuable to keep him out of the lineup that first season. On his first night in the big leagues, Padres’ manager Roger Craig recognized Ozzie’s amazing defensive abilities. “Ozzie has shown me he can play shortstop in the majors. I’ve never seen anyone with better hands, or quicker hands and feet,” Craig said.

On August 7, 1915, future Hall of Fame outfielder Sam Rice made his major league debut as a relief pitcher for the Senators. Rice pitched regularly his first two seasons, before settling in as an outfielder. In his debut, he had unusual defensive help – future Hall of Fame pitcher Walter Johnson started and played right field in place of the injured Washington regular.

Lou Gehrig made his first major league appearance on June 15, 1923, pinch-running for Wally Pipp, whom he would eventually replace as the Yankees’ first baseman. Gehrig would hold a firm grip on the position for 2,130 straight games until he was diagnosed with a rare fatal disease, though his consecutive games streak would not begin until 1925.

Sometimes rookies get no respect at all. Pie Traynor didn’t get a chance to play for the Pirates until the final days of the 1920 season, in the second game of a doubleheader on September 15. Even then, he didn’t start the game, but came in as a defensive replacement for Bill McKechnie. An unknown rookie, Traynor was listed in newspaper accounts and the box score as “Trainor.” He did collect his first major league hit that day, and within a few years everyone in the National League knew how to spell his name.

The most important debut of them all

One of the most significant debuts by any player occurred on April 15, 1947, in Brooklyn’s Ebbets Field. Playing first base that day for the Dodgers was Jackie Robinson, the first African American to play in the majors in modern times. Robinson batted second in the Brooklyn order and was 0-for-3, but he was involved in the Dodgers’ three-run rally in the seventh inning, which proved to be the winning margin. Robinson dragged a bunt toward first base which Braves’ first baseman Earl Torgeson fielded but threw away into right field. Two days later in similar fashion, Robinson collected his first major league hit, a drag bunt against the Braves. In that same game, on April 17, 1947, future Hall of Famer Duke Snider made his major league debut. Playing left field, Snider collected a single and scored a run, but it was another rookie who stole the spotlight – Johnny “Spider” Jorgensen, who had a monster day, driving in six runs on a home run and two doubles. On that day it was “Spider” not “Snider,” that had Dodgers’ fans talking.

share on:
Dan Holmes

Dan Holmes

Dan Holmes is the author of three books about baseball, including Ty Cobb: A Biography. He previously worked for the National Baseball Hall of Fame, and Major League Baseball Advanced Media. He lives in Michigan where he writes, runs, and enjoys a good orange soda now and again.
0 0 votes
Score this Baseball Egg article
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments